Ordered delivery after staying at a nearby hotel. Prime rib dip was tasty, requested chips instead of fries- they gave fries and they weren't really hot and fresh tasting. Clam chowder was creamy and full of clams. Coconut shrimp were crunchy and sauce had a kick to it-nice portions too. Salad was a bit pricey but tasted as described. Highlight was the key lime pie- a large slice of tangy pie with rich whipped cream- so deliciously crave worthy!

Definitely one of the last of the original gems in the east Bay Area. Great ambience, beautiful people, lovely scenery and the food selections are top tier! The prime sliders, clam chowder and the crab dip are just a little of the many delicious options at this restaurant. It's a whole vibe, no matter the day and time.

Best restaurant in the San Leandro Marina! The food and service are both amazing! Our server Angela was so sweet and accommodating and knew the menu well to help us make our entree selections. Everything on the menu is solid and delicious! The chefs love to cook and take pride in the dishes they serve. The restaurant reminds you of an old ship and has a cool laidback vibe. It's causal but also nice enough for a special occasion or date night. Perfect for large parties and meetings as well. They have a great happy hour menu from M-F. I have been eating here for a long time and every time I come I leave happy and say why don't I eat here more often! We came to celebrate my parent's wedding anniversary and the staff treated us so well. When you go ask for Angela as your server and I know you'll have a wonderful time! ‍

I came here for my friend's going-away dinner, and it was a large party with my young daughter in tow. Angela was our server, and she was incredible! She handled everything flawlessly, accommodating every special request without missing a beat. Throughout the evening, she was so friendly and bubbly, making the experience even more enjoyable. Her exceptional service truly made the dinner memorable!

This is the first time we come to this place to celebrate my birthday, I love the vibes surrounding, very unique and beautiful! I would highly recommend the tasting samplers, Bolognese and the Creme Brulee cake!! Horatios Staffs are nice, Specially to Khin, great services!

Came here for my friends birthday. I had the Shrimp and Crab Fettuccini and what I loved about it was that it had chili flakes which gave it that slight spice kick to it which I loved. Also another plus to it was that, there was a lot of shrimp. Normally dishes like this have maybe 3 or 4 pieces of shrimp. I believe this dish had 5 nice size pieces of shrimp. Their complementary bread was also very delicious. I would like to say it had parmesan on top. We had to try our best not to get full with just their bread. Everyone really enjoyed their dishes and I don't think anyone had any issues. Only issue was that the salmon was slightly on the dry side but lemon and the sauce from my pasta helped it with flavor. They were pretty busy and the service was not bad at all. We did have to wave down our server from time to time, but they were right on their feet and got whatever we had asked for. We never had to wait long to be served. I get it, they were busy with a lot of tables but even just being a little more attentive to your tables will help. We wanted to ask for more bread, but it took a while for our water refills that we did not want to bother them or wait to long. Someone does need to check on the bathrooms more often because the stall I went into did not have toilet paper. That is about it.

Food was great! Just FYI if you're coming here for prime rib, prime rib is not ready until after 3 PM. I came here in the morning with some family and there was no ribeye on the menu. I asked for ribeye and they were still able to bring me one.

My fiancé introduced me to Horatio's, and I can honestly say without a doubt... I am a fan of this place! We made reservations for NYE, and we were seated right away. First, our server Esther was wonderful. She was very attentive. Our food came out so quickly too. They only had their holiday menu, which was actually a good deal. For $60-65 per person, you get your choice of soup or salad, main entree, and dessert. Dishes: 1) Warm brie with macadamia nut crust 2) Lobster bisque 3) Clam chowder 4) Almond crusted sea scallops 5) Prime rib 6) Creme brulee 7) Cheesecake Drinks: 1) Lychee lime soda 2) Amalfi stroll Overall, everything was delicious but the cheesecake for me was a miss. It was way too sweet for my liking. My fiancé's 16 oz prime rib was literally the perfect cut. Not very fatty at all! Their complimentary garlic bread is also so tasty. There is plenty of parking here which is a plus!

Thank you so much, Bill for being such a great manager! You took the time to check on us at our table and see how we were doing constantly and I love how you lead by example. My wife and I are not always able to get out much these days because we have a special need Son that requires a lot of attention. When we go places like Horatio's, we have to hire a babysitter for us to eat out. It's very important to us when we do this because we want to make it count. I want to give a special thanks to Chad for always being our great server and to Maria for also being a great server! The food is amazing here! The Service is awesome! If you want a nice relaxing place by the San Leandro Marina water with an elegant setting this is definitely a place to visit.